
Among the many companies I’ve worked for and roles that I’ve filled, was a brief time as a Teacher and Assistant Center Director at Huntington Learning Center. I worked there from 2001 to 2004, at just the right time to be part of the public debate around the passage of the NCLB, better known as the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001, which was signed into law on January 8, 2002. I still have very fond memories of my time there and learned much about myself and about office life, office politics, and just how the education system so tightly straddles the line between everyday American life and American politics. The education system, in my opinion, is the lynch pin of the entire American socio-political system we have built, but I digress.
In the year 2000, then candidate George Dubya Bush ran in part on a platform of education reform. After he became President, Bush proposed a plan to reform the education system through the Department of Education. Among the many goals of the plan were to introduce a common set of measurable educational standards throughout the nation, to hold schools receiving federal funding accountable for achieving those standards, and to ensure every student had access to “highly qualified” teachers. These were lofty goals given our country’s historically and consistently poor performance on standardized tests compared to other countries. This bill was intended to unite the country, focusing it on a consistent set of performance and quality standards and ensuring that every student, regardless of race, religion, or income had access to a quality education. The conversation around my Learning Center, however, was quite mixed.
As you might imagine, many of the teachers at that Huntington Learning Center were current or former teachers themselves. Some were public school teachers and some were private. Others, like me, weren’t teachers at all, at least not outside of those walls. I was a college student at the time, a Mathematics major enrolled at UMBC, with a passion for my subject and a decent rapport with the other children. It probably didn’t hurt that I was also a former student of that very Huntington Learning Center either.
Many were confident that the introduction of new national standards was only an excuse to eliminate teachers who weren’t complying or wouldn’t comply with the Government’s narrative.
Before I discuss some of the varying viewpoints and perspectives, I should probably discuss some of how Huntington worked then. Struggling students would be assessed upon enrollment. We would identify skill gaps based on their grade and develop a program to bring them to match or exceed the expectation. That program would include individualized instruction with frequent assessments to ensure that they were making measurable progress. It was disciplined and regimented while also allowing some flexibility and independence.
Perhaps because of that rigorous learning environment, I found myself agreeing with much of what the NCLB was proposing. Perhaps because of my youth, being so soon after graduation from the public school system and still being in college at the time, I further found myself agreeing with the sentiment that allowing teachers to have near total liberty regarding the establishment of curriculum or enforcement of policy was not the way to ensure universal quality. Perhaps it was because I was at that point in my life as a young man, that almost all young men seem to endure, where I questioned the authority of the established political parties in and even supported some of the tenants of libertarianism. (As a short aside, long-time readers or listeners will recall that this was when I registered as “Unaffiliated” and in fact it was the bipartisan support for this bill that helped me realize that neither “side” was the villain I once thought they were.) Still, perhaps it was because September 11th was such a short time before then that I felt national unity, especially in the education system, was more important than ever. Whatever the reason, I will state unequivocally, I supported this bill.
At Huntington, however, support was not so strong. Many teachers were skeptical, even pessimistic, about the Government’s motives. Many were confident that the introduction of new national standards was only an excuse to eliminate teachers who weren’t complying or wouldn’t comply with the Government’s narrative. My opinion at the time was that these teachers were, at best, just afraid of the inevitable addition to their workload, or at best, afraid of being exposed as bad teachers who didn’t really provide any value to their students. (I cringe now at how naive I was. And I worry still at how naive I might still be.) Regardless of my opinion, however, I was confident that there was an educational crisis in this country. American students consistently performed worse than their international peers, especially in Science and Mathematics. If something wasn’t done, there could be a complete collapse of scientific discovery and technical innovation, or so I thought. And how can you solve a problem you can’t (or refuse) to measure. We had to find some way to understand why and then fix it, teachers and their own opinions be damned.
In any case, the rest is history. Almost every fear regarding how the NCLB would destroy the system of education has been realized. “Teaching to the test” is now the rule, not the exception. “Failing forward” to avoid the appearance of poor student outcomes is now the expectation, and there is intense pressure on teachers to accommodate parents and please the administration. Performance comparisons to international peers are still every bit as one sided and worrying. But the collapse I expected never came. The one thing this country seems to do REALLY well, finance, took care of that. Now, we just hire those more apt students from other countries, promising them life in a freer society and significantly greater earnings potential. The famous expression, voiced by Matt Damon in the movie “The Martian”, really should have been “I’m gonna have to finance the shit out of this!”
That is the real crux of why the NCLB hurt instead of helping our education system. It emphasized the economic problem and completely ignored the social one. In the intervening years since passage of the NCLB, I have witnessed the societal change in my peers, and most importantly, in my own children. College tuition has exploded, increasing year over year well beyond the rate of CPI inflation (see the below graph and note the very prominent inflection point right around 2002 when the NCLB was passed). The race to outperform peers to be awarded scholarship or grant money or to obtain an internship opportunity or to participate in competitive extracurriculars dominates primary and secondary education. Students and teachers are overworked well beyond the norm in most other professional settings. Teaching is no longer seen as an endeavor where adults can contribute back to the younger generation, imparting knowledge and wisdom; teaching is now seen as an endeavor that must add value to their students. I saw this change start even while I was working at Huntington as more SAT and college preparatory programs were added to the list of offered services. I saw this change continuing while my wife was a Student Support Assistant in the public school system. It seemed her colleagues were especially concerned with preparing their students for the next standardized test, or with allowing students more time to turn in assigned work, or with making accommodations for overburdened or distraught parents. And I saw this change with my own children, constantly pushed forward even when they had little to no grasp of the concept they were supposed to learn.
To be clear, I’m not blaming the students, the teachers, or the parents and those that do need to widen their window. To look at the situation now without any knowledge of the past is fool-hearty and callus. Students, teachers, and parents are all rational actors in an economic system, each doing the best they can with limited resources and support. And before you say “Ah, so it’s the government’s fault!” I don’t really blame them either. IT”S US!
We have to stop assuming we can solve a social problem by making it an economic one.
We have to stop assuming we can solve a social problem by making it an economic one. Economics, while a useful tool for solving many problems, is not the catch all that it is often purported to be. And economic theory seems to be more and more aware of this fact. I recall a study by Shampanier, Mazar, and Ariely called “Zero as a Special Price: The True Value of Free Products”. The study reviewed the results of an experiment whereby students were offered candies either for free or for 1 cent. When the candies were free, the students took more only one on average. When the candies were 1 cent, the students took 4 on average. This study is often cited to indicate how people act in response to social norms (“Don’t be greedy”) as compared to market norms (“Maximize value”). In my opinion, a similar market response has occurred because of the passage of the NCLB (and now the Every Student Succeeds Act or ESSA passed in 2015 which basically retained the regulatory concept while making the executive framework the responsibility of the States). Of course, I still believe, as one might expect from a “Math person”, that measuring student achievement and teacher performance is critical to understanding the problem we face. But this isn’t an economic problem; making funding contingent on those metrics will only encourage a race to the bottom where every child is left behind.


Julius Knapp III
Entrepreneur

Corrections, Clarifications, and Addendums:
[27:49] The Prichard Scale in Dead Poets Society was actually a paraphrase of a theory of measuring poetry by Laurence Perrine in this book.
[58:12] Musk talked about the H1b visas. There is no such thing as a 21b visa. Here is a CBS article on what companies use them most.
[58:45] Economic Policy institute agrees that companies underpay those on H1b visas. However, Forbes disagrees.
[59:25] Brian thinks it was this article on NPR that he heard about Apple and China.
[1:00:00] This is the Smarter Every Day grill brush episode that Julius talks about.
[1:06:00] Why Cats Paint: A Theory of Feline Aesthetics by Heather Busch and Burton Silver
[1:06:00] Musicophilia: Tales of Music and the Brain, Revised and Expanded Edition is most likely the book Julius was mentioning here.
[1:09:00] Sam learns geography by Coach. Cheers.

© 2025 The Ascendant Project
For more content and information:
Please visit www.theascendantproject.com
Discover more from The Ascendant Project
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.