Our American Tradition

S1 E18 “Our American Tradition” by Julius Knapp. Interviewed by Brian Smyers
Julius Knapp

Julius Knapp III

Entrepreneur

I still remember the first protest I saw. I was about 15 or 16 and had traveled to Long Island with my parents and siblings to visit my grandmother and other relatives. We went to Roosevelt Field Mall, memorable for the massive Zeppelin that hung above the food court, to get lunch and do some shopping. Almost immediately after walking through the door, we saw a small group of demonstrators holding signs and shouting. I don’t recall exactly what they were shouting or even exactly what they were protesting, although I believe it was a protest against animal cruelty and the sale of fur. The police were there, attempting to remove them from the mall and quiet the protest. I still remember the young woman who was being tackled to the ground and arrested while continuing to shout.

At first, I was scared; we had only just walked in and were immediately introduced to this small shouting crowd. And I still remember my father, a New York native, jokingly exclaim “Welcome to New York”. To be clear, I had already been to New York and Long Island many times by that point in my life but had never seen such a public demonstration. And my quiet life in the central Maryland suburbs did little to prepare me for the experience.

Almost immediately afterwards, however, as I was riding up the escalator and thinking about what I had just seen, I realized the importance of that moment. That kind of civic action, common throughout the United States (honestly, there’s a protest or demonstration happening every few days in this country if you look for it), is not a global experience. It’s somewhat unique to America that we can shout, get angry, demonstrate our displeasure at some public policy, and come together to address grievances. I’m sure to many outside the United States it seems chaotic at best and destructive at worst, but the reality is that it binds us together in our common struggle and encourages us to have the hard discussions.

I may not support your message, but I’m glad to have the opportunity to discuss

During almost every period of civil unrest in my lifetime- from the Iraq and Afghanistan war protests, the Occupy and Tea Party movements, and to the more recent Black Lives Matter protests- I have witnessed or been a part of some conversation with friends, coworkers, fellow parishioners about the subject of those protests. Rather than holding us back, it drives us forward. The developer in me would say “It’s not a bug; it’s a feature”. That’s why the more recent Hands Off and No Kings protests are so important. Not necessarily because of what they stand for, although those are worthy causes, but because they show that democracy is still alive, our republic is still strong, and that the discussion continues, like it or not. All Americans- those for and against those causes, those who showed up and those who didn’t- should be proud of that fact.

Regardless, we should not belittle the bravery of those protestors by hiding their faces or silencing their message. They knew the risks and showed up and spoke out anyway, and it would diminish their impact by trying to hide that fact. If you stand for a cause, regardless of message or party affiliation, I support you and I’m proud to call you a fellow American. I may not support your message, but I’m glad to have the opportunity to discuss. And at the risk of being controversial, if you just don’t want to have the discussion, if your view is that you don’t want people to bring that into your “safe space” or that you don’t want the issue “forced down your throat”, then you might be in the wrong place.

Now, if you’re still with me, let me provide some further guidance. Recent studies show that nonviolent campaigns, that is peaceful protests or civil resistance, are twice as likely to succeed as violent ones. Erica Chenoweth and Maria J. Stephan studied 323 major resistance campaigns from 1900 to 2006 and found the rate to be 53% versus 26%. Nonviolence is key to gaining public sympathy, lowering the barriers to participation, and gaining media attention (not every journalist is a war reporter; if you want the news to show up, make sure there is a safe environment for them to conduct interviews and record the story). Peace also requires planning and discipline which also helps to sustain the movement. Most importantly, though, remaining nonviolent is critical to realizing the second finding from Chenoweth’s and Stephan’s research. That is, that expanding the campaign to include at least 3.5% of the population, what Chenoweth and Stephan have dubbed the 3.5% rule, guarantees its success.

I am providing this guidance because current trends would suggest that we may need to continue the tradition demonstrated by that crowd at Roosevelt Mall, to peacefully and publicly protest the status quo. And it will require all of us, Liberals and Progressives, Libertarians and Conservatives, and all those outside and in-between, to further our gains while not losing what we have. Regardless, be proud of your fellow Americans, even if their being loud, rowdy, or obnoxious, and honor their participation. If nothing else, listen to some Sam Cooke, and take heart.

My more recent experience with protests is much more uplifting. Westminster, my hometown, is a strangely active community politically. Shortly after moving here, I witnessed a protest of Monsanto right in the center of town. Sometime after that, there was a Pro-Life rally. There have been several demonstrations by various religious groups and churches here. During Covid, many people protested masks and virtual learning. More recently, residents participated in both the Hands Off and No Kings protests. In a way, Westminster is a flashpoint for civic participation and civil discussion. It’s part of its charm, even if I sometimes must wait longer to get across Main Street, and I’m proud of my community. Every. Time.


Corrections, Clarifications, and Addendums

[23:00] Here is a link to an ABC news article following up on Juli Briskman, who was the cyclist who flipped off Trump’s motorcade in 2017.

[41:00]Maria Stephan’s last name is pronounced Steh-fin.

[44:08] The Arab Spring started when Mohamed Bouazizi died of self-immolation (he set himself on fire). He did this to protest police harassment and government corruption in Tunisia. This started a pan-Arab protest movement that resulted in the Tunisian government being overthrown, Egypt’s and Yemen’s government being overthrown more than once, civil wars in Libya and Syria, Protests and governmental changes in Western Sahara, Morocco, Oman, and Lebanon.

[45:26] The Muslim Brotherhood did take power in Egypt but was overthrown by the military on July 3rd 2013.

[48:34} 5 million people attended the No Kings Rallies.

[53:35] The Koch Brothers funded the first Tea Party website in 2002 through their PAC Citizens for a Sound Economy. Further funding of the Tea Party movement came from another of their PACs, Americans for Prosperity

[54:00] Huma Abedin married Alexander Soros. AI messed up stating Alexander’s father, George was dating her. ugh. Another reason AI sucks donkeyballs.


© 2025 The Ascendant Project

For more content and information:

Please visit us at www.theascendantproject.com


Discover more from The Ascendant Project

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply